Drives for offloading camera cards: formats, speed and cables
The fastest, safest offload is two fast SSDs, each formatted for the computers that will read it, each plugged straight into the computer with a cable rated for its speed. The detail below explains each part, so you can buy and set up the right kit once.
1. Format each drive for whoever has to read it
The format barely changes speed on an SSD. In side-by-side tests the same 30 GB copy took about a minute whether the SSD was APFS, Mac OS Extended or exFAT (ProVideo Coalition), and exFAT has measured around 5 to 10% slower than APFS for writes on recent macOS (Larry Jordan). So choose by who needs the drive:
| Who reads the drive | Format | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Macs only, SSD | APFS | Apple's format for flash storage, and what Apple recommends for external drives used with Final Cut Pro (Apple, Apple). |
| Macs only, spinning hard drive | Mac OS Extended (Journaled) | APFS isn't designed for spinning disks and can fragment them badly; Mac OS Extended stays the better fit there (Howard Oakley). Don't encrypt it: from macOS 28, encrypted Mac OS Extended drives aren't supported (Apple). |
| Macs and Windows PCs | exFAT | The one format both can read and write without extra software (Apple). Two cautions below. |
| Windows PCs only | NTFS | Windows' own journaled format. A Mac can read NTFS but not write to it without extra software. |
| Nobody, for video | FAT32 (MS-DOS) | No file on it can be 4 GB or more, and most cameras write clips larger than that. |
exFAT, two cautions. It keeps no journal, so a drive pulled out mid-write can lose its folder records: always eject it before unplugging, and prefer a journaled format (APFS, Mac OS Extended, NTFS) for the master copy when only one platform needs it. And format exFAT drives on the Mac: Windows' default settings for large drives can produce an exFAT drive that macOS won't open. If you must format on Windows, choose an allocation unit size of 1024 KB or smaller (details).
2. The slowest link sets the speed
Every byte travels card → reader → cable → port → drive, and the copy can only go as fast as the slowest of those. With two drives, both copies run at the speed of the slower drive.
An example from our own test (Mac Studio, 22 GB from a CFexpress Type A card in a USB reader): the card read at 908 MB/s; a Finder copy reached 484 MB/s to one SSD but only 293 MB/s to another. The second SSD, not the card, set the pace, and any copy to both drives at once would go at its speed.
3. Cables and ports matter as much as the drive
- Many charging cables are slow for data. Plenty of USB-C cables, Apple's own USB-C charge cable among them, carry data at only 480 Mb/s (USB 2), about 40 MB/s in practice, and look just like a fast cable (Apple). Use the cable that came with the drive, or one marked 10 Gb/s, 40 Gb/s or with the Thunderbolt logo on each plug.
- Adapters and hubs. The same SSD that copied 30 GB in a minute took 12 minutes through a USB-A adapter (ProVideo Coalition). Hubs and docks share their speed between everything plugged into them. Plug card readers and fast drives straight into the computer.
- "20 Gb/s" drives on a Mac. USB 3.2 Gen 2×2 drives and readers run at 10 Gb/s, about 1 GB/s, on Apple silicon Macs; USB4 and Thunderbolt drives run faster (Eclectic Light). The same applies to many PCs without a Gen 2×2 or USB4 port (Digital Camera World).
- Check the link. On a Mac, System Information › USB (or Thunderbolt/USB4) shows the speed each device is connected at; "Up to 480 Mb/s" means the cable or port is the bottleneck.
4. Not all SSDs keep their speed
An offload is a long, steady write: exactly what exposes an SSD's limits. Many SSDs write very fast into a small cache, then slow down once it's full, and cheaper ones (often QLC) slow down a lot. Some also slow when they get hot. Reviews that test sustained writes, rather than a short benchmark, tell you what a drive will really do on a full card (for example Tom's Hardware). Spinning hard drives are fine for an archive copy but are much slower and fragile while running.
A good setup
- Two SSDs of the same model, each at least as fast as your fastest card reader, formatted APFS (Mac only) or exFAT (Mac and Windows).
- Each drive and the card reader on its own port, straight into the computer, with the cables that came with them.
- A third copy, or an archive on spinning disks, made later, away from the cards.
- Copies checked by reading them back, with an ASC MHL record on each drive, before any card is formatted.
Shotlore's own Offload copies to every drive at once, reads every file back and writes the ASC MHL record. It also reads the MHL records that OffShoot, Silverstack and other tools write, so every card shows as verified or not when you add the copies to a job. See the manual.